March 14, 2026

The Commodity Trap

Do you feel like your customers buy only because of price? That’s the Commodity Trap, and you may have set the trap yourself.

Most sales teams don’t lose deals because of price.
They lose them long before price ever comes into play.

Today’s buyers research independently, talk internally, define requirements, and shortlist vendors before ever engaging a seller. In fact, research suggests that roughly 70% of the buying process is complete before a buyer speaks with a rep.

So when the conversation finally happens, something subtle but dangerous occurs.
The buyer says what they want to buy.
And the rep focuses on delivering it.
Your sale moves from consultative to transactional.

Very few reps pause to explore why the buyer believes they need it in the first place. Even worse, many reps unintentionally push the conversation toward price themselves by asking about the budget too early.

Instead of learning:
• The objective the buyer wants to achieve
• The problems preventing them from achieving it
• How those problems are impacting the buyer and their company
• The upside of success and the risk of doing nothing

…the conversation jumps to:
“Do you have a budget?”
At that moment, the sale quietly shifts from value to cost.

And when every seller enters late in the buying process and focuses on:
• The product
• The specs
• The quote
• The budget
…the buying experience feels the same across every vendor.

When the experience feels the same, buyers default to the only clear differentiator left:
Price.

This is the commodity trap.
The data reinforces the risk:
• 53% of deals marked “lost” were actually winnable
• 65% of lost deals stem from poor discovery
• 67% of lost sales are due to weak qualification

Winning sales teams change the conversation.
They slow down.
They ask better questions.
They uncover impact.
They learn the customer’s risk of maintaining the status quo.
They influence decision criteria.
They help buyers define what success really looks like.

If you don’t help define the value, the buyer will define it for you.
And it will usually be price.

Price dominates when value isn’t discovered, defined, and defended.

Recent Posts

Urgency Comes From What’s at Stake for the Buyer

reat reps “wallow in the pain”—not in a negative way, but in a disciplined, curious way where you resist the urge to move too quickly to solutions. Instead of uncovering one or two issues and jumping to how you can help, these great reps ask questions that help them really understand what’s sitting below the waterline.

read more
Worst “Kate” Scenario

But too much optimism can actually derail a deal.

Most deals don’t fall apart because the customer suddenly changes their mind.

They fall apart because of issues that weren’t anticipated early enough:

read more
Fill the Bucket Before You Fix the Leak

I see this all the time with reps who aren’t using an insight selling model. They are just peddling whatever they sell, and they waste a lot of time having conversations with potential customers that end too quickly because they jumped at the first problem they heard.

read more
When Automation Goes Wrong

Automation should make things easier — not colder, not stricter, not more rigid.
The companies that win are the ones who blend smart systems with accessible humans, and who treat feedback as an upgrade path, not an inconvenience.

read more
When Experience Becomes a Cage: Why Some Long-Tenured Sales Reps Fear Change

I spend a lot of time coaching seasoned sales professionals — people who have weathered recessions, survived industry disruption, and sold through eras most younger reps have only read about. You’d think that level of resilience would also translate to adaptability. And yet, some of the most experienced reps are the ones who struggle the hardest to change how they sell.

read more

0 Comments